The Tyranny of “Best”: Finding What’s Truly Right for Your Financial Future
What if the relentless search for the “best” financial product is the very thing preventing you from building real wealth for your financial future?
The Question That Revealed Everything
When my dear friend Michelle* (*name changed for privacy) reached out last month, I could hear the exhaustion in her voice. She’d been researching endowment plans for over six months, and each time we spoke, she was approaching it from a completely different angle.
First, she wanted to understand capital guarantees. Then she shifted to comparing projected yields. Next, she was deep into researching insurers’ track records for delivering on their projections. Each conversation revealed another layer of comparison, another dimension to research, another reason to delay the decision.
“Can you just tell me which insurer has the best track record for delivering their projected returns?” she finally asked. “I need to make a decision, but I’m terrified of choosing wrong. What if I pick the second-best option and regret it later?”
I understood her completely. In a world of overwhelming financial choices and high-stakes decisions, we desperately crave a clear winner—a top-ranked name we can trust and confidently proceed with. We want the safety of knowing we’ve chosen the “best.”
But here’s what Michelle’s six months of searching had actually cost her: lost time her money could have been growing and compounding, countless hours of anxiety-filled research, strained conversations with her husband about “waiting until we’re absolutely sure,” and growing doubt about her own judgment with each new angle of comparison.
My answer wasn’t the insurer name she expected. It was a gentle reframe: “What if the search for the ‘best’ is actually the tyranny holding you back from the financial security you’re trying to create?”
What would it feel like to make financial decisions from confidence and clarity rather than fear of missing out on some mythical “best” option?
Understanding the Tyranny of “Best”
Every time I work with families trapped in the endless search for “best,” I’m reminded that this pursuit isn’t just tiring or inefficient—it’s a subtle form of tyranny that creates anxiety, leads to comparison paralysis, and causes us to overlook the most important variable in any financial equation: you and your unique circumstances.
The Hidden Costs of Chasing “Best”
The Emotional Toll: Constant comparison creates perpetual doubt—every decision feels potentially wrong because there’s always another option you haven’t fully researched yet.
The Opportunity Cost: While you’re searching for perfection, your money sits idle. Days become weeks, weeks become months, and compound growth opportunities vanish forever.
The Relationship Strain: Partners disagree about when “enough research” becomes “enough,” creating tension around money decisions that should bring security and peace.
The Paralysis Effect: The more you research, the more options you discover, and the harder the decision becomes—knowledge increasing confusion rather than clarity.
Have you ever felt stuck in this cycle of endless research, unable to move forward because you’re afraid of choosing “wrong”?
The Three Pillars of the “Best” Tyranny
Pillar 1: The Crystal Ball Mirage (The Projection Fallacy)
The Seductive Illusion: We naturally gravitate toward charts showing the highest historical dividends or most impressive bonus projections. Numbers feel concrete. Past performance feels like evidence. Illustrations look like promises.
The Uncomfortable Truth: Those beautiful projection illustrations are exactly that—illustrations based on assumptions about future economic conditions, investment returns, and claims experience that literally no one can predict with certainty.
The Rearview Mirror Problem: Choosing financial products based solely on past performance is like driving while only looking in the rearview mirror. You have some information about where you’ve been, but you’re completely blind to the road ahead—curves, obstacles, and opportunities you’ll actually encounter.
What Actually Matters: Instead of asking “Which insurer had the best past returns?” the empowering question becomes: “Which product structure, policy terms, and features genuinely serve my specific timeline and goals?”
Which question feels more aligned with building genuine long-term security—chasing past performance or evaluating future credibility?
Pillar 2: The Ignored Variable (The Personal Fit Fallacy)
Where Tyranny Becomes Most Personal: The “best” product in a vacuum is a completely meaningless concept if it’s a terrible fit for your actual life circumstances, timeline, and emotional comfort.
The Empowering Reframe: Instead of asking “What is THE best endowment plan?” we ask: “What is the best endowment plan FOR ME, given my unique situation?”
The Variables That Actually Matter:
Your Time Horizon:
- Do you need funds in 10 years for your child’s university education?
- Or in 20-25 years as retirement income supplement?
- Different timelines require completely different product structures
Your Liquidity Requirements:
- Can you confidently lock funds away for the full policy term?
- Might you need emergency access to capital during unexpected life events?
- Early surrender penalties can devastate “best returns” if life circumstances change
Your Risk Temperament:
- How do you genuinely feel about non-guaranteed return projections?
- Does potential volatility keep you awake at night?
- Does your spouse share your risk comfort level, or will this create relationship tension?
Your Goal’s Specific Purpose:
- Is this for non-negotiable milestone (child’s education that MUST happen)?
- Or more flexible goal (retirement supplement where timing can adjust)?
- Different goal types require different certainty levels in product design
The Reality Check: A product that’s objectively “perfect” for a 25-year-old with high risk tolerance, long timeline, and flexible goals is likely entirely wrong—possibly even harmful—for a 50-year-old planning for certain retirement in 15 years.
Which variables feel most important to honour in YOUR financial planning—other people’s past returns or your own future needs?
Pillar 3: The Paralysis of Comparison (The Analysis Paralysis Fallacy)
The Endless Research Trap: The quest for “best” often spirals into endless cycles: more research, additional spreadsheet comparisons, seeking one more expert opinion, discovering new products to evaluate, starting the comparison process again…
The Massive Hidden Cost: While you’re perfecting your analysis, your capital isn’t working for you. Compound growth hasn’t begun. The clock is ticking. The real cost isn’t choosing a slightly suboptimal product—it’s the years of growth lost to indecision.
The Empowering Truth: A “good enough” plan implemented today and consistently funded for 20 years will dramatically outperform a “perfect” plan that remains a spreadsheet fantasy for months or years while you continue researching.
The Math of Delay: Consider this: Starting to invest today means your money begins compounding immediately. Delaying for several months while continuing to research means losing that compounding period forever—time you can never recover, regardless of which “better” product you eventually choose.
A good plan started today will often outperform a marginally better plan started months later, simply because time in the market consistently beats timing the market.
What would it feel like to make a confident, good-enough decision today rather than a perfect decision someday?
My Financial Resilience Approach to Breaking Free
When families come to me exhausted from chasing “best,” we shift the conversation entirely—from seeking the elusive perfect product to architecting the most resilient plan for their unique situation.
🏗️ GROW – Building Long-Term Wealth That Actually Serves You
The Liberation Question: “Does this product’s structure genuinely support MY specific wealth-building timeline and goals?”
What We Explore Together:
- Does the endowment’s maturity date align with when you actually need the funds?
- Do the premium payment terms fit your current cash flow without creating stress?
- Does the growth structure (guaranteed vs. non-guaranteed components) match your risk comfort?
- Will this help you build what you need, when you need it, in ways you can sleep peacefully with?
The Shift: It’s not about highest projections—it’s about whether the product architecture genuinely serves your specific wealth-building journey.
🛡️ PROTECT – Safeguarding What Truly Matters
The Liberation Question: “Does this product’s structure and terms provide the security MY situation requires?”
What We Explore Together:
- Policy’s guaranteed vs. non-guaranteed components (reading actual documents, not just marketing)
- Company’s historical consistency in delivering on policy illustrations
- Policy features that protect you during unexpected life changes
- How surrender values work if circumstances force early exit
The Shift: Protection isn’t about brand comparisons or marketing promises—it’s about understanding specific policy terms and choosing products whose structure genuinely serves your security needs.
🏛️ PRESERVE – Ensuring Your Money Is There When You Need It
The Liberation Question: “How does this endowment help me preserve capital and ensure funds are available for my future milestone?”
What We Explore Together:
- Guaranteed maturity benefit forming your security foundation
- Company’s track record of capital preservation through market cycles
- Surrender values if life circumstances force early exits
- How this integrates with your broader estate and legacy planning
The Shift: Endowments are often primarily about capital preservation with modest growth—ensuring money is protected and available for your child’s education or retirement supplement regardless of market chaos.
Which of these three pillars feels most important to strengthen in your current financial planning?
Real Families Breaking Free from “Best”
The Exhausted Researcher’s Discovery
“I spent 6 months comparing plans from every possible angle. Then I realised I was missing my daughter’s childhood while researching her education fund.”
Her Tyranny Experience: Michelle (from our opening) spent over six months researching endowment plans, shifting between different comparison criteria with each new conversation—capital guarantees, then yields, then insurer track records, then policy features. Each new dimension of research led to more questions rather than clarity.
Her Breakthrough Moment: During our conversation, I asked: “If you implemented a good-enough plan today and spent those research hours with your daughter instead, which would matter more in 10 years—having the theoretically optimal product, or having those irreplaceable moments with your child?”
Her Liberation Strategy:
- Selected product with features matching her timeline and conservative risk preference
- Chose policy structure that felt clear and understandable to her
- Implemented plan within 2 weeks instead of continuing endless research
- Redirected research energy into quality family time and her own professional development
Her Peaceful Outcome: Months later, her endowment is growing steadily, her anxiety about “missing the best” has vanished, and she’s regained countless hours with her daughter that would have been lost to comparison paralysis. Most importantly, she realised the specific projection differences she was agonizing over have become irrelevant—what matters is that her money is working consistently toward her daughter’s education.
Time insight: Perfect decisions delayed cost more than good decisions implemented promptly.
The Analysis Paralysis Couple’s Alignment
“My husband and I spent 6 months disagreeing about which plan was ‘best.’ We were letting research destroy our relationship.”
Their Comparative Trap: David and Sarah had fundamentally different research approaches—he wanted exhaustive analysis; she wanted confident decision-making. Their endowment search was creating relationship tension.
Their Reframe Discovery: Instead of “Which plan is objectively best?” they explored: “Which plan allows us both to feel confident and aligned about our retirement planning?”
Their Aligned Approach:
- Acknowledged they had different risk temperaments requiring different strategies
- Chose conservative endowment matching Sarah’s security needs
- Balanced with separate growth-focused investments honouring David’s higher risk tolerance
- Both felt heard, respected, and confident in the integrated approach
Their Relationship Outcome: Financial planning became collaborative discovery rather than competitive research. They implemented their plan within 3 weeks and redirected energy toward shared goals rather than endless debate about “best.”
Relationship insight: Financial alignment matters more than financial perfection—plans that partners confidently support together outperform “optimal” plans creating ongoing tension.
The Opportunity Cost Awakening
“I finally realised what my months of searching for ‘best’ actually cost me in lost compound growth potential. The wake-up call was powerful.”
His Perfectionism Cost: James spent many months researching endowment plans, seeking the “perfect” option with highest projected returns for his newborn daughter’s education fund.
His Reality Check: Had he started with a “good enough” plan months earlier, his regular contributions would already be invested and beginning to compound. That lost time—and the compounding that could have occurred—can never be recovered, regardless of which “better” product he eventually chose.
His Implementation Decision: Chose endowment with clear policy terms and features he understood, implemented immediately, committed to consistent funding rather than continued optimization searching.
His Wisdom Gained: “The ‘best’ plan that never gets funded is infinitely worse than the ‘good’ plan that compounds consistently over 18 years. Time is more valuable than perfection, and you can’t buy back lost compounding periods.”
Opportunity insight: Compound growth lost to indecision can never be recovered—time is the one financial resource you can’t buy back.
Which family’s journey resonates most with your own experience of seeking “best” financial solutions?
Finding Freedom in “Fit” Over “Best”
The Questions That Actually Matter
Instead of: “Which insurer has the best historical returns?” Ask: “Which product offers features and terms matching my timeline, risk comfort, and specific goals?”
Instead of: “What’s the highest projected return I can find?” Ask: “What guaranteed benefits do I need, and what non-guaranteed potential feels comfortable for my situation?”
Instead of: “Am I missing a better option somewhere?” Ask: “Does this plan help me achieve my specific goal with confidence and peace of mind?”
Instead of: “What if I choose wrong?” Ask: “What if choosing ‘good enough’ today serves me better than choosing ‘perfect’ someday?”
The Liberation Framework
Step 1: Clarify Your Non-Negotiables
- What is this money specifically for?
- When do you absolutely need it available?
- What level of certainty do you require for peace of mind?
Step 2: Assess Genuine Fit
- Does the product timeline match your goal timeline?
- Do the premium requirements fit your cash flow comfortably?
- Does the risk profile align with your emotional comfort?
- Are the policy terms and features clear and understandable to you?
Step 3: Verify Product Appropriateness
- Do the policy features serve your specific needs?
- Is the guaranteed vs. non-guaranteed split comfortable for you?
- Does the product structure make sense for your situation?
Step 4: Implement and Move Forward
- Make the decision confidently
- Set up automatic funding
- Schedule periodic reviews (annually, not monthly)
- Redirect research energy toward living your life
Which step feels most important for you to focus on in breaking free from the tyranny of “best”?
Your Path From Tyranny to Freedom
The Empowering Reframe
The next time you find yourself asking for the “best” financial product, pause. Recognise the tyranny in that question and grant yourself the freedom to seek what genuinely fits your unique life.
The real “best” is never a product on a shelf competing for highest projections.
The real “best” is the peace of mind that comes from a plan that is:
- Resilient enough to weather economic changes
- Personalised to your specific circumstances and timeline
- Strategically aligned with your actual goals and values
- Implementable today rather than perfect someday
It’s the confidence that allows you to sleep peacefully at night, knowing your financial future isn’t built on a myth of perfection, but on a solid foundation designed specifically for you.
What would it feel like to replace the exhausting pursuit of “best” with the peaceful confidence of “right for me”?
Your “Fit Over Best” Discovery Framework
Phase 1: Clarity Over Comparison
- Define your specific financial goal and non-negotiable timeline
- Assess your genuine risk comfort (not what you think you should feel)
- Identify your liquidity needs and potential life changes during policy term
- Clarify what “good enough” would look like for this specific goal
Phase 2: Fit Assessment Over Feature Hunting
- Evaluate 2-3 products with features and terms matching your criteria
- Compare how each product’s structure serves YOUR specific timeline and goals
- Assess guaranteed benefits vs. illustrated projections for each option
- Consider which product’s terms and features you understand most clearly and feel most confident about
Phase 3: Implementation Over Optimization
- Make confident decision within defined timeframe (2-4 weeks maximum)
- Set up automatic premium payments eliminating ongoing decision fatigue
- Document your decision reasoning for future confidence during market volatility
- Schedule annual review (not monthly monitoring) aligned with life changes
Phase 4: Living Over Researching
- Redirect research energy toward actually living your financial goals
- Celebrate implementation rather than second-guessing past decisions
- Focus on consistent funding rather than continuous product comparison
- Trust compound growth to work its quiet magic over time
Which phase would bring you the most freedom from the tyranny of seeking “best”?
The Freedom Michelle Discovered
Remember Michelle from our opening, exhausted after 6 months of endowment research from every possible angle? Several months after our conversation, she sent me a message that brought tears to my eyes:
“I finally understand what you meant about the tyranny of ‘best.’ I chose a good endowment with policy features I understood that matches my daughter’s university timeline. I set up automatic payments. And then I did something revolutionary—I stopped researching.
“In the months since implementing my plan, I’ve:
- Reclaimed countless hours I would have spent continuing research
- Experienced zero anxiety about ‘missing better options’
- Actually enjoyed my daughter’s childhood instead of stressing about optimizing her education fund
- Watched my contributions begin compounding rather than sitting idle while I continued researching
“The wildest part? I don’t even remember the specific projection differences I was agonizing over. But I vividly remember the weekend I spent at the beach with my daughter instead of researching—that memory is priceless.
“The ‘best’ plan isn’t the one with the highest illustrated return. It’s the one that lets you live your life confidently while your money works quietly in the background.”
Michelle’s wisdom captures the entire journey: Perfect financial products don’t exist, but peaceful financial confidence absolutely does—once you liberate yourself from the tyranny of chasing “best.”
What would you do with the time and energy you’re currently spending searching for “best” if you made a confident decision today?
Your Financial Planning Deserves Freedom
Choosing financial products isn’t about perfection, optimization, or winning some imaginary competition for “best returns.” It’s about creating structures that serve your actual life while bringing peace rather than perpetual anxiety.
The most successful financial plans aren’t the ones with highest illustrated projections—they’re the ones that get confidently implemented, consistently funded, and allowed to compound quietly over decades while you focus on living the life they’re designed to support.
What would financial decision-making feel like if it brought clarity and peace rather than anxiety and endless comparison?
Ready to Break Free From the “Best” Tyranny?
Don’t let the exhausting search for “best” prevent you from building the financial security you’re trying to create. The right conversation can transform overwhelming comparison into confident clarity in weeks instead of months or years.
As The Resilience Planner, I’m deeply passionate about helping families break free from comparison paralysis and discover financial solutions that genuinely fit their unique circumstances. Using my Financial Resilience approach, we’ll explore what actually matters for YOUR situation and find clarity that brings peace rather than perpetual doubt.
I invite you to a complimentary 30-minute “Fit Over Best” Discovery Session where we’ll:
- Explore what’s keeping you stuck in comparison paralysis and how to break free
- Discover the 2-3 variables that actually matter most for your specific financial goals
- Uncover which product features serve your situation vs. which are just marketing noise
- Discuss how to make confident decisions within 2-4 weeks instead of endless months
- Create a clear action plan for implementation that brings peace rather than perpetual second-guessing
Schedule a Discovery Session here: https://cammietan.com/discovery-session
Because when it comes to financial planning, the freedom of “right for me” beats the tyranny of “best” every single time.
What would it feel like to make your financial decision with confidence this month instead of continuing the exhausting search for perfection?
Michelle, David, Sarah, and James are fictitious names used for illustration purposes and do not refer to any particular persons.
Disclaimer: This content has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any Singapore government agency. References to “Singapore” refer only to the geographical area served. The information is for general knowledge and educational purposes only, is accurate at the time of writing, and may be subject to change. It should not be considered financial or legal advice. Please consult a licensed financial advisory representative or legal advisor for personalised recommendations. E&OE.
About the author: Cammie currently holds a financial advisory license for distribution of insurance and collective investment scheme products, and has an Estate Succession Practitioner certification. Trained as an Architect and being a brain tumour survivor, she identifies herself as The Resilience Planner in Personal Finance. Her approach to financial advisory is consultative – she encourages her clients to be participative and ask questions. She believes that because Personal Finance is personal, she works with clients to create tailored solutions that suit each individual’s unique needs and life goals.
